I think Rogue One definitely has some issues worth criticising, but I really do like it a lot. For me it’s easily up there with the original trilogy. In fact if I were to rank just the Star Wars movies, no other media, I’d probably put it at number 3, despite its flaws.
It’s a movie where an absolute banger of a third act has to do a LOT of work to make up for a very weak first two acts, but my god the third act is so fucking good that it somehow pulls it off. The space battle, the assault on the tower, everyone doing their little part to help push towards one tiny little victory… that fucking Vader scene… it really does stick the landing.
I thought after Andor it was clear the Star Wars universe was fine without anymore Skywalkers.
Hard agree. Andor is the best thing anyone has ever done with Star Wars.
Yes, I’m including the original trilogy. I said what I said.
As a huge fan of the franchise, I think
andorRogue one was the first actually good movie in the universe.Yes, including rots and OT
Edit: mixed up rogue one and Andor lol
Andor is for sure one of the best shows, up there with Clone Wars for me
I think Rogue One definitely has some issues worth criticising, but I really do like it a lot. For me it’s easily up there with the original trilogy. In fact if I were to rank just the Star Wars movies, no other media, I’d probably put it at number 3, despite its flaws.
It’s a movie where an absolute banger of a third act has to do a LOT of work to make up for a very weak first two acts, but my god the third act is so fucking good that it somehow pulls it off. The space battle, the assault on the tower, everyone doing their little part to help push towards one tiny little victory… that fucking Vader scene… it really does stick the landing.
Its significantly better than anything else sw related