Or rather, what’s the Marxist stance on office jobs? Truth be told, I’m writing this while a bit inebriated on my day off lol. But I was still wondering about that question.
Obviously I realize that there are extreme levels to this, like working for the armed forces or a bank, which are clearly indefensible. But what about an office job for a market chain, for example? Or for a multinational seller of cheap goods? Is providing work for such companies considered unethical? Where does one look to find criticisms of one’s workplace? And how does one juggle the need for money for survival while only having “soft” skills?
I am open to constructive criticisms and I am genuinely asking. After all, I have started only recently learning Marxist theory and deprogramming myself while reflecting more deeply about society and myself.
Ironically (or shamefully), I just noticed that while I was busy reading basic texts about theory, I forgot to incorporate any sort of deeper analysis of the practical side of it all.
No need to expose yourselves, but what are some of the jobs that principled Marxists are drawn to? Where do you draw the line when looking for a new job?
(I would also be very thankful for any suggestions about books or articles as well! I am quite curious about finding the correct personal balance between need for work and ethical concerns)
Asking a related question in this thread:
I know there is the whole “no ethical consumption” but at what point do you say “too far”?
Ended a friendship over them working for a defense contractor (think image of a missile as their website’s header).
Even then I could excuse it if they were able to argue their reasoning, but they wouldn’t admit that the work they do is terrible. I know another guy who works in the industry and he basically said he doesn’t do jack shit and being a leech is better than someone doing work, but this other person didn’t defend their position at all.
Completely shut down the discussion. Even though they’re an Arab, they still didn’t want to face the fact that their work is quite literally raining bombs on their extended family.
I told him that he is a zionist due to his work propping up the zionist entity and that’s what ultimately lead to the collapse of the friendship. I still stand by what I said though.
For me the “defending it” is the line. So long as the person is honest in doing it just to pay their bills, that’s good enough. And it’s obviously better if they’re an actual comrade and do praxis some other way in their life.
I’ve also ended a friendship over a friend trying their damnedest to portray the landlord and hedge fund corporation she worked at as “progressive actually”. I think there’s this tendency to force oneself to believe one’s work is always a net positive for the world somehow.
I think that’s a sensible red line to draw. You have to draw a line somewhere. It’s not like that person couldn’t find another job elsewhere.