Unfortunately we all know what happens when you tell hackers that something’s going to be very hard to break into.
I understand that they were excited about the idea and wanted to share it with gamers, but if they actually wanted to give the system the best chance of success, they should’ve kept their mouth shut.
It was a really interesting food for though, especially since both cybersecurity and game development are my main areas of focus (I work part time in offensive security, and part time as game dev). I has actually motivated me to start considering that I might give data-mining this game a try, because I’m really interested in how he wants to solve the many issues present.
I’m betting it would probably be mostly leaning into “security by obscurity”, but if that’s the case, throwing a gauntlet like this wasn’t a good idea. Because every technically sound solution I came up with was a nightmare from game design standpoint, and I couldn’t came up with any puzzles or secrets that wouldn’t be extremely complex, mostly because you just require a really large problem and input space for it to not be brute-forcable at any of the reverse-engineerable stages.
Also, I have a soft spot for clever marketing tactics, and this one is amazing.
Unfortunately we all know what happens when you tell hackers that something’s going to be very hard to break into.
I understand that they were excited about the idea and wanted to share it with gamers, but if they actually wanted to give the system the best chance of success, they should’ve kept their mouth shut.
Yeah but also free advertising.
at least it probably saves you from the worst fate: that nobody cares about the game enough to try to discover the things
(I’m fairly sure that datamining is not that common outside highly popular games, well assuming the data isn’t neatly in plaintext)
Considering it’s being published and promoted by a huge YouTube video game channel it’d never be likely to stay under the radar.
It was a really interesting food for though, especially since both cybersecurity and game development are my main areas of focus (I work part time in offensive security, and part time as game dev). I has actually motivated me to start considering that I might give data-mining this game a try, because I’m really interested in how he wants to solve the many issues present.
I’m betting it would probably be mostly leaning into “security by obscurity”, but if that’s the case, throwing a gauntlet like this wasn’t a good idea. Because every technically sound solution I came up with was a nightmare from game design standpoint, and I couldn’t came up with any puzzles or secrets that wouldn’t be extremely complex, mostly because you just require a really large problem and input space for it to not be brute-forcable at any of the reverse-engineerable stages.
Also, I have a soft spot for clever marketing tactics, and this one is amazing.
… you work in offensive security and… game development
Are you … Thor ? 😁