UPDATE: So, apparently it’s mostly fake, taken from this article [translation] (where they even mention some kind of VCS).
However, even though it’s not as absurd, it’s a great read and a pretty wholesome story, so I recommend reading the article instead. And I’m even more convinced that this studio really does not deserve any of the hate they are getting.
Here is my summary of some of the interesting points from the article:
PocketPair started as a three man studio, passionate about game development, that couldn’t find an investor for their previous games even though they’ve had really fleshed out prototypes, to the point where they just said “Game business sucks, we’ll make it and release it on our own terms”, and started working on games without any investor.
They couldn’t hire professionals due to budget constraints. The guy responsible for the animations was a random 20-yo guy they found on Twitter, where he was posting his gun reload animations he self-learned to do and was doing for fun, while working as a store clerk few cities over.
They had no prior game development experience, and the first senior engineer, and first member of the team who actually was a professional game developer, was someone who ranomly contacted them due to liking Craftopia. But he didn’t have experience with Unity, only Unreal, so they just said mid-development “Ok, we’ll just throw away all we have so far, and we’ll switch to Unreal - if you’re willing to be a lead engineer, and will teach us Unreal from scratch as we go.”
They had no budget. They literally said "Figuring out budget is too much additional work, and we want to focus on our game. Our budget plan is “as long as our account isn’t zero, and if it reaches zero, we can always just borrow more money, so we don’t need a budget”.
For major part of the development, they had no idea you can rig models and share animations between them, and were doing everything manually for each of the model, until someone new came to the team and said “Hey, you know there’s an easier way??”
It’s a miracle this game even exists as it is, and the developer team sound like someone really passionate about what they are doing, even against all the odds.
This game is definitely not some kind of cheap cash-grab, trying to milk money by copying someone else’s IP, and they really don’t deserve all the hate they are receiving for it.
I guess I’m a little confused, because wasn’t their previous game Craftopia? I’m fairly certain that game sold relatively well for an indie game, at least 25,000+ copies if you base it off the All Time Peak Players on Steam Charts. For a small team of just a few people, that’s a decent chunk of money (I think it sold at $30 around launch, so roughly $750k for 25k copies sold before Steam takes its cut). Craftopia came out in 2020, so they’re saying they’ve learned virtually nothing in 4 years, not counting the dev time Craftopia had?
I enjoy Palworld, I think it’s a fun game that has a lot of potential, but I’m not sure I’m fully buying into some of these responses.
As a side note, a lot of Craftopia people complain they abandoned that game, but looking on Steam it shows several recent updates across the last year, with one even coming out just yesterday and a huge one in November 2023 and a new roadmap posted in December 2023. So, I’m not really sure where those players are coming from regarding that.
Regardless, I’m looking forward to what Palworld grows into, as I really do think they have something rather special here. It’s got a lot of rough edges and a couple core design problems, but those can eventually be addressed with some hard work. Hopefully they use the massive cash influx they’ve achieved with their recent success and hire some competent, seasoned developers to come in and get their shit in order. I’m not holding my breath too much, though (remember when we thought Valheim devs would spend their game success lottery money to massively boost that game’s content and polish?).
It turns out that most info from the screenshot is false, there’s a better article that’s written by the actual developer linked in the updated post.
He did talk about them not having a budget plan, which was a fairly long part of the article, but can be summed up like this:.
He also further down mentioned actual numbers of how much went into the development:
Agreed on both points - I am skeptical they are such “amateurs”, and it also doesn’t necessarily seem like a cash grab considering how Craftopia is faring. It does seem like there’s way too much buzz currently going on however, it’s hard to say what is true or what is just an outright lie… hoping to learn more and see how this progresses in a few months. Also hoping they stay dedicated to improving palworld more than the valheim devs did (meaning barely anything, thank god for the modding community there doing what little they can to keep the game alive).