• 0 Posts
  • 83 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 26th, 2022

help-circle


  • I’m not a big YouTube watcher or smash bros expert but I do know this guy does a lot of work hosting for the Smash Bros melee scene out of his pocket. Notably in 2022 when Nintendo shut down the Smash melee world championship tournament which was basically fully organized and ready to go until Nintendo stabbed them in the back. This guy Ludwig pulled through and got a legitimate tournament up and running to fill the void Nintendo made.





  • I actually just got done with some western leftists on the western pacific/China situation. I thought we had mutual respect between us but then they tried to call me white when they knew I’m not and they knew I was from one of those areas. And called me unhinged/deranged. So being deprived of my humanity was cool. I should have just done what you did and ask for sources.

    fuckin hell mate I don’t think I’ve ever been mad about an online confrontation like this. sorry I needed the vent. the steam is coming out my ears, nose, and cuticles. It’s just actually physically tiring.








  • I agree with some of what you said but mainly disagree with your analysis of poor libertarians. I will use the USA as a model for my post.

    Historically we should expect to find more economic fluidity amongst white people, meaning they’d be able to move from worker to labour aristocracy/petty bourgeoisie. The classic example would be for a white worker to labour for a time at a decent paying job, save money, buy a house, and start a business.

    So as we see, the class lines would be more blurred in the past because of the stronger wages and free time of labourers, and so there becomes no real need in the present to tie poorer libertarians historically to immaterial things since their interests in the past were absolutely material and aligned.

    With the polarization of the economy the class lines become more defined. So then the poor libertarians, stuck without any mobility as workers, become very reactionary and try to reclaim a time that is past. Those who are petit bourgeoisie themselves, even though they may not be poor, are threatened with becoming workers again.

    This plays out nowadays as the libertarian to fascist pipeline, though American libertarianism is already inherently reactionary by being supported by colonialism and imperialism (as opposed to, for instance, a petit bourgeoisie in another country trying to rid itself of the shackles of colonialism).

    In the American case libertarianism is a petit bourgeois (and white) ideology that fits very well with the standard Marxist model of the petit bourgeois being the source of fascism.





  • Yeah fetishizing philosophy is fairly common in western spheres. But we Marxists are not philosophers, we are scientists and with that comes observations and experimentation (real world implementation, praxis, etc ).

    I come from a natural sciences background so my honest feelings is that a lot of that pre Marx stuff is, while nice to know, not particularly necessary.



  • It’s fairly obvious you arent well read on socialism. The way you think about history, development of society and its transformations are clearly incorrect given the other stuff you’ve posted (for example, you don’t understand how propaganda works). So we don’t need to explore very much further.

    You are not taught how to grapple with those topics properly in America and in fact are taught an older, outdated manner that is instilled into you since birth by everyday interaction with parents, friends, education, media, the list goes on. This is the true nature of propaganda.

    What you should be concerned with is the scientific interpretation of history, since growing up in America, you do not learn this but rather the ideological one that, even when you say you criticize the US, often simply ends up supporting the US, who has been the biggest barrier in modern times to historical progress.

    Have a good day and don’t take it personally. I’d wager 90%+ of us here started out like you.